Although
the Second World War
brought death and destruction to the world, it ironically signified
a breath of life into the stagnant aircraft industry. Aircraft manufacturers,
limping along in the red from the scant prewar government orders, underwent
an amazing metamorphosis and evolved into an intricate system with expansive
components and a single goal: to produce immense quantities of the best
military aircraft in the world. This goal fostered mass expansion, subcontracting
and specialization, and the conversion of various civilian manufacturing
facilities into aircraft subassembly plants. The most interesting and
significant effect of the war effort in the aircraft industry was the
"good will " and "together we win" attitude of the many aircraft manufacturing
companies. This cooperation and teamwork approach led directly to the
development of the revolutionary Aircraft War Production Council in
April, 1942. (24A) The Council, comprised
of the heads of most west-coast aircraft companies, played an invaluable
role in securing allied victory in the air, and the war.
On May
16,1940, President Roosevelt electrified the nation when, addressing
a joint session of congress, he asked for a defense budget of $1.2
billion to make "our defenses invulnerable, our security absolute."
(25) Roosevelt went on to ask for a fantastic
50,000 planes a year. It was clearly time for the aircraft industry
to "roll up their sleeves and get to work". Production, which
had always occurred on a small scale needed to be carried out at tremendous
levels. Manufacturers now faced the daunting task of overcoming the
red tape and logistical nightmare of an industry-wide mass reorganization
and production ramp-up for war.
The
first order of business was mass expansion. A thousand different systems
of "popgun" capacity had to be enlarged to handle the fantastic all-out
war production program. The raw statistics of this mobilization are
impressive, but their magnitude can not truly be appreciated until one
realizes exactly what these numbers represent. "Expanding floor space"
most often meant the construction of new buildings, and these new buildings
had to be filled with the proper tools and machines. Expansion also
required finding enough skilled people to run all of this added equipment.
Experienced engineers and machinists were very hard to come by at this
time, and many aircraft companies resorted to looking through college
records to find men with engineering degrees who might be working in
an unrelated field to fill their rosters. (26)
After the dust had cleared, the Glenn L. Martin company had roughly
doubled its size while quadrupling its workforce (27)
, Consolidated had expanded by about 87 percent (28)
, and Boeing's expansion program pushed their floor space to an incredible
148 acres of area devoted entirely to aircraft production. (29)
Expansion was by no means restricted to bomber manufacturers as each
of the United States' 13 aircraft companies undertook similar programs
to try to keep up with the huge demand for every type of military aircraft.
It soon became
quite clear that even at their accelerated production levels, the individual
companies had no realistic chance of keeping up with the new flood of
orders on their own. The ingenious solution for the industry came in
the form of a threefold strategy: massive subcontracting, conversion
of "non- essential" civilian plants, and cooperating production pools.
Subcontracting proved
to be a very logical and efficient use of the manufacturing industry
as a whole. By subcontracting various parts, the aircraft industry was
able to utilize the talents and facilities of other plants and industries
whose business had been curtailed by priorities or other restrictions.
Boeing's
production of the B-17 was an excellent example of the benefits of subcontracting.
In fact, subcontracting of the Fortress was so extensive that only the
fuselage and inboard wing sections were actually built at the Boeing
plant. (30) The real beauty of the Boeing
program was that it was planned and developed before the actual
big push of orders occurred. By placing various "educational orders"
of selected parts normally produced at the home plant, farsighted Boeing
officials developed a roster of perspective subcontractors, "by the
time government requirements for increased production were voiced, Boeing
was ready with a selected, tentative list of plants to which it could
turn for assistance." (31) Another outstanding
feature of the Boeing program is that rather than individual parts,
entire assemblies were being produced by the "farm companies" and shipped
completed, to Boeing so that all they had to worry about was final assembly.
Finally, Boeing's subcontracting program "farmed-out" most of the tedious
machining work, leaving their equipment relatively free to handle the
various very important last minute design improvements, experimental
"cut ant try" parts, and "Blitzkrieg" items; modified components that
had to be rushed through so as not to delay production.
Hand in hand with
subcontracting came product switchover. Many small companies that were
producing civilian products were "switched over" to produce various
components for the aircraft industry. In these plants, their products
were most often a total mismatch, but the way they were producing
them lended itself, after a few simple changes, to creating a new bomber
part factory. The following is a typical example as related by Martin
director of procurement T. J. Dunnion:
Not long ago the general manager of a firm in the Midwest called the
Martin plant by phone. Priorities had knocked his milk can business
into a cocked hat and he wondered if his factory could be useful to
us in some way. He had the idea that he could convert it into a shop
to make wing spars for our bombers. Bombers need a lot of wing spars;
we were interested at once. A procurement engineer. ..went to look over
the plant. He found its facilities unsuitable for the making of wing
spars, but ideal for turning out exhaust stacks. Result: today the milk
can factory is furnishing exhaust stacks for the B-26 Marauder." (32)
The
third leg of the aircraft industries' production triad was the production
pool system. This system truly showed the spirit of cooperation of the
day as one manufacturer sacrificed his own designs and completely retooled
his plants to produce another company's aircraft that was judged to
be more vital. As a result of pooling, the B-17 was being built by Boeing,
Lockheed, and Douglas (33), while the
B-24 was built by Consolidated, North American, Ford motor corporation,
and Douglas as well. This system, which required some companies to turn
over all designs (and design secrets) to "competitors" to facilitate
greater production of essential aircraft, was an incredible testament
to cooperation within the industry. "It was an intricate swirl of production.
The AAF was doing the quarterbacking and coaching of this giant team.
The AAF worked out the plays and called them, named the players, sent
in substitutes to meet strategic situations, and finally rammed the
ball over the line on the fighting front. Never before had there been
such team play in industry." (35)
Amid the tide of
cooperation that flowed through the industry, and the country, in early
1942, there was talk among officials of the need of an "aircraft council"
to dominate and coordinate the aircraft manufacturers' efforts. In fact,
the idea was not new. For some time the group of eight Southern California
aircraft heads had met every fortnight at the Santa Monica Douglas plant
to brainstorm for solutions to the common problems that the industry's
explosion had thrust upon them. These informal director's meetings proved
very beneficial to their respective companies as for almost every problem,
one builder had devised an approach that helped the other seven.
Finally,
the eight west coast presidents "officialized" their meetings by forming
the Aircraft War Production Council. The council originally consisted
of: Harry Woodhead, Consolidated; Donald
Douglas, Douglas; L. Cohu, Northrop; "Dutch"
Kindelberger, North American; T.C.
Ryan, Ryan; Richard Millar, Vultee; C. Gross, Vega; and R.
Gross, Lockheed. The Council was later reduced to seven when Consolidated
and Vultee merged, Lockheed and Vega merged, and Boeing -an associate
member- joined. (35A) The AWPC's first
president, J. H. "Dutch" Kindelberger of North American, summed
up the council's new procedure when he told his department heads: "from
now on, were going to give our competitors all we've got, with no hedging
or holding out. They're going to do the same for us. " North American
engineers, as well as those from the other seven companies, sent outlines
of their trade and manufacturing secrets to the AWPC offices to be circulated.
(36) Once manufacturers on the east coast
caught on to the benefits the consortium offered, they formed a similar
committee, and merged with the AWPC in April 1943. The entire
industry now had a common data base of knowledge and pooled resources
to work from.
Douglas' advanced
research in wing and fuselage aerodynamics was dumped into the pool,
as was Northrop's Heliarc Welding Technology. In fact, Northrop offered
to donate the special torches, (which took two years of engineering
to produce) to the council. Similarly, Boeing offered its advanced plastics
research, and pledged to continue the research of behalf of all the
companies. And so on down the list. Each company offered what they had.
A total of almost 18,000 technical reports were shared, an exchange
that had saved over one million engineering man hours by early 1944.
(37)
Often,
designs for whole sections were provided by one company to another,
saving countless hours engineering time. Such was the case for the landing
gear of the P-61
Black Widow and the dive-brake flaps for the P-51
Mustang. Northrup, who had little experience with tricycle landing
gear, received detailed plans from North American for the landing gear
which had performed well on their B-25.
With a few slight modifications, it worked equally as well on the Black
Widow. Under similar circumstances Vultee sent North American blueprints
for necessary dive-brake flaps for the P- 51, a $250,000 (38)
gift to the war effort.
Designs and plans
were not the only thing "shared" by the AWPC. The member companies together
owned a massive quantity of raw materials. In order to prevent production
stoppages when one company ran out of a material, the "AWPC's" materials
were channeled wherever necessary. These "over the back fence" borrowings
of materials averaged about 1,375 per month in 1943 (39),
and each one represented another production stoppage avoided.
Machine
time was another valuable commodity swapped within the AWPC. It was
not uncommon to see one company do another's work for the benefit of
a third, when in 1942 when a seemingly contagious string of equipment
breakdowns plagued the industry, every company inevitably wound up doing
machining work for another. Finally, a list of "key" machines and times
they were available appeared in the council office as a standby for
any company who needed it. (40) And the
production lines kept rolling.
William F. Peters,
manager of the AWPC for the second half of the war, stated the following
as the AWPC's major contribution toward victory: "pooled engineering
built quality into all of our airplanes. It saved time and built them
faster, of course, but the most important factor was quality. This was
a qualitative war, as was proved. ..on every front where modern airplanes
fought yesterdays planes and shot them down, sometimes ten to one or
better." (41)
Thus the aircraft
industry marched into war, not by falling into lock step, but by equipping
the short-legged man with stilts to match the strides of his long-legged
teammate... The progress of the fastest was property of them all,
and, as in any team play, the score belonged to everyone regardless
of who carried the ball over the line. (41A)

|